The Most Common Restaurant Website Mistakes and How to Fix Them

September 29, 2025

By RocketPages

The Most Common Restaurant Website Mistakes and How to Fix Them


Your restaurant website is often the very first impression potential diners have of your business. A poorly designed or unoptimized site can drive them away before they even see your menu. While many restaurant owners know they need a website, most unknowingly make critical mistakes that hurt their Google rankings, reservations, and overall customer experience.


Mistake 1: Not Optimizing for Mobile


Why This Hurts You

Over 60% of diners search for restaurants on their phones. If your site isn’t mobile-friendly, users will bounce quickly. Google also penalizes non-responsive websites.


How to Fix It
  • Use a responsive design builder like Rocketpages, which ensures your website adapts to any screen size.
  • Test your site on multiple devices and browsers.
  • Ensure menu and reservation buttons are large and easy to tap.

Case Study: Street Eats

Street Eats, a food truck business, switched to Rocketpages. Their bounce rate dropped by 40% and online orders doubled once their site became fully mobile-responsive.


Checklist
  • ✅ Mobile-friendly navigation
  • ✅ Tap-friendly CTA buttons
  • ✅ Fast mobile loading speed


Mistake 2: Slow Loading Times


Why This Hurts You

Google penalizes slow sites. Diners won’t wait more than 3 seconds for your page to load. Every second delay can reduce conversions by 7%.


How to Fix It
  • Compress food and interior images.
  • Use hosting optimized for speed (Rocketpages includes built-in performance enhancements).
  • Minimize third-party scripts.

Case Study: Café Lumière

After switching to Rocketpages, Café Lumière’s homepage load time went from 5.2 seconds to 1.8 seconds, improving their Google ranking and reservations.


Checklist
  • ✅ Compress images
  • ✅ Minify code
  • ✅ Use Rocketpages hosting


Mistake 3: Outdated or Hard-to-Find Menu


Why This Hurts You

Your menu is the most visited page. If it’s outdated, buried in PDFs, or difficult to read, customers leave.


How to Fix It
  • Keep menus updated in real-time.
  • Use on-page menus rather than PDFs.
  • Rocketpages provides dynamic menu management.

Case Study: The Green Table

The Green Table updated their site with Rocketpages’ dynamic menus and saw a 55% increase in online orders in 3 months.


Checklist
  • ✅ Menus updated weekly
  • ✅ Mobile-friendly formatting
  • ✅ No PDFs


Mistake 4: No Clear Calls-to-Action (CTAs)


Why This Hurts You

Without clear CTAs, visitors don’t know what to do next.


How to Fix It
  • Add bold “Reserve a Table” or “Order Now” buttons.
  • Place CTAs above the fold.
  • Use Rocketpages templates with optimized CTA placements.

Case Study: PizzaHub

After adding CTA buttons across their site, PizzaHub’s reservation requests grew by 70%.


Checklist
  • ✅ CTA above the fold
  • ✅ One CTA per page section
  • ✅ Clear wording


Mistake 5: Ignoring Local SEO


Why This Hurts You

Most restaurant searches include “near me.” Without local SEO, you miss high-intent customers.


How to Fix It
  • Claim and optimize your Google Business Profile.
  • Ensure NAP consistency.
  • Add local keywords.
  • Rocketpages includes local SEO features.

For a deeper dive, see our detailed guide: How to Build a Restaurant Website That Ranks on Google.


Case Study: Thai Spice

Thai Spice optimized local SEO via Rocketpages. They ranked #1 for “best Thai near me” in their city, doubling their weekend reservations.


Checklist
  • ✅ Verified Google Business Profile
  • ✅ Consistent NAP across directories
  • ✅ Local keyword integration


Mistake 6: Poor Visuals


Why This Hurts You

Low-quality images make your food unappetizing and lower trust.


How to Fix It
  • Hire a professional food photographer.
  • Use high-resolution but compressed images.
  • Showcase ambiance, staff, and dishes.

Case Study: Ocean Breeze

Ocean Breeze replaced stock images with professional photos and saw a 38% increase in website engagement.


Checklist
  • ✅ Professional food photos
  • ✅ Optimized image size
  • ✅ Showcase people + atmosphere


Mistake 7: No Online Ordering or Reservations


Why This Hurts You

Diners expect convenience. Without online ordering, they go elsewhere.


How to Fix It
  • Enable online booking directly on your site.
  • Avoid relying only on third-party apps.
  • Rocketpages integrates reservations and ordering systems.

Case Study: Bistro Bella

After enabling online reservations on Rocketpages, Bistro Bella’s direct bookings increased by 120%.


Checklist
  • ✅ Online booking system
  • ✅ Direct ordering integration
  • ✅ Easy checkout process


Mistake 8: Ignoring Reviews and Testimonials


Why This Hurts You

Reviews influence dining decisions. Ignoring them means losing trust.


How to Fix It
  • Encourage happy customers to leave reviews.
  • Display testimonials on your homepage.
  • Reply politely to negative reviews.

Case Study: Grill House

Grill House showcased testimonials on Rocketpages and saw a 30% rise in table bookings.


Checklist
  • ✅ Testimonials on homepage
  • ✅ Google review link
  • ✅ Respond to all reviews


Mistake 9: Weak Branding


Why This Hurts You

A generic site makes your restaurant forgettable.


How to Fix It
  • Use consistent fonts, colors, and logos.
  • Share your brand story.
  • Rocketpages provides branded templates.

Case Study: Café Aroma

After rebranding with Rocketpages, Café Aroma saw a 25% boost in brand recall in customer surveys.


Checklist
  • ✅ Consistent design elements
  • ✅ Clear brand story
  • ✅ Customized Rocketpages template


Mistake 10: No Tracking or Analytics


Why This Hurts You

Without data, you can’t improve your website.


How to Fix It
  • Add Google Analytics & Search Console.
  • Use Rocketpages analytics dashboard.
  • Track clicks, reservations, and orders.

Case Study: Sushi House

By monitoring analytics through Rocketpages, Sushi House identified underperforming menu items and adjusted promotions, increasing revenue by 18%.


Checklist
  • ✅ Google Analytics installed
  • ✅ Conversion tracking enabled
  • ✅ Regular performance review


Final Thoughts

A restaurant website can make or break your business. By avoiding these common mistakes and fixing them with simple strategies—and by leveraging Rocketpages—you’ll create a site that not only attracts visitors but also converts them into loyal diners. From mobile optimization to branding, SEO, and online booking, the fixes are straightforward with the right tools.


Ready to fix your restaurant website mistakes and start ranking higher on Google?

Recent Articles

Stay inspired with our latest deep dives into the dining world. From choosing the perfect restaurant for life’s milestones to deciding between a night out or cozying up with takeout, each article offers humanized insights, practical tips, and stories that celebrate the joy of food and hospitality. Explore what’s new and discover guides that make every dining decision more meaningful.